The Nanfang / Blog


American With Good Intentions Ridiculed For Helping Victim In China

Posted: 09/18/2014 2:07 pm

nanjing broken vase foreignerThe “broken vase” trick is a scam in China where con artists feign being accident victims in order to win cash settlements from unsuspecting people that think they are at fault. It’s an old scam with many variations, and it’s a main reason why Chinese people are usually more than reluctant to help anyone in need, lest they became victims of fraud themselves.

Adding to the number of savvy Chinese that can spot such a scam, Weibo user ”Piggy Sister That Doesn’t Want To Grow Up” published pictures that show “a clear and brazen case of the broken vase scam”.

READ: What the Broken Vase Scam Is, and How to Avoid Being Duped

The photographs show a man with an injured leg in the middle of the road outside the Nanjing Red Cross Society Hospital on the morning of September 17. A three-wheeled vehicle idles beside him as pedestrians and cyclists simply pass the fallen man.

When a non-Chinese man wearing dark green clothes comes forward to give help, he is criticized for having fallen for the “broken vase” scam. Of this, the Weibo user said, “The laowai can never understand…”

Many local shop owners said the incident happened after 7am when a non-Chinese man was seen speaking to the victim. Then he left, according to a reporter.

nanjing broken vase foreigner

“Reminded Me of My Mother”

The reporter was able to track down the would-be good samaritan, a 30-something expat from the USA named “Sam” (a pseudonym) who is currently working in Nanjing. Sam said seeing the victim reminded him of his own mother, who was recently involved in a traffic accident herself.

However, Sam said he became very doubtful when he saw bystanders gathering to laugh at him. One bystander waved a hand at him and shouted, “No, no, no!”

READ: Guangzhou Drunk Drivers Extorted in Staged Collisions

Sam was not able to communicate with the man, who would only cover his forehead with his left hand and sporadically let out a shrill cry of pain. Sam saw he couldn’t do anything, so left. He said he couldn’t understand why the bystanders were trying to get him to stop.

nanjing broken vase foreigner

“Broken Vase” or No “Broken Vase”?

For this to be a “broken vase” scam, the con artist would try to blame the fraud victim (Sam) for the accident and attempt to extort money, which didn’t happen. However, local Nanjing residents were still suspicious because the incident happened just outside of a hospital.

The Yueya Lake police sub-station confirmed the incident was not a “broken vase” scam, but something else entirely.

The story is this: Police from the Yueya Lake sub-station responded to a burglary at 1pm at Zhonghe Bridge after a man fell from a second story apartment. This unidentified man was not confirmed to be a thief, and was taken to Nanjing Red Cross Society Hospital to treat his broken leg.

The police say the unnamed man blamed police for the fall, and wants them to pay his hospital bill. Upon being discharged, the man lay down in the middle of the road as a way to claim his rights.

nanjing broken vase foreigner



  • Zen my Ass

    So, this guy broke his leg falling from the 2nd floor and blamed the police for that… the American was lucky enough to not be drawn into.

  • notpilgrims2

    “The story is this: Police from the Yueya Lake sub-station responded
    to a burglary at 1pm at Zhonghe Bridge after a man fell from a second
    story apartment. …
    The police say the unnamed man blamed police for the fall, and wants them to pay his hospital bill.”

    WTF? If the series of events as represented in the article is correct, the man fell then blamed the police–who arrived after he fell–for causing him to fall. It was still a case of a man trying to extort money then.

    • Truthful

      Another completely misleading headline that has nothing to do with the event being reported. First of all, there was no legitimate “victim”! Secondly, the subject of the article should not be the foreign man walking by – the subject of this story is really the typical Chinese scammer lying on the ground.

      The article doesn’t make sense because it was written by TheNanfang’s Resident Wumao “Chinaman Charles Liu” who seems to harbor a particular hatred for “foreigners” and almost always tries to work in the whole “foreigners are naive/stupid/silly/bad/etc”-angle into every article.

      This is why thenanfang is slowly going the way of the wumao echinacities, (being pressured into?) handing their expat websites over to locals [perhaps] in order to ‘maintain harmony in the great Chinese nation’ (lol)

      Per usual, just a pathetic display of your deep-rooted insecurities, Mr. Chinaman Charlie.

  • Toothless

    I dumped a motorcycle in the middle of the road one time. Every fucker walked on by.

  • Pingback: Hao Hao Report

  • 老 baRt 巴特 ‘homikus’

    WTF I just read? Because that’s certainly not what I would expect having clicked the link/title.

  • Ronald Paredes

    …and my question is why are not this fucking scammers being jailed? because as far as I know that is a crime and if isn’t it should be, Taking money away from somebody under false pretences is a crime

Keep in Touch

What's happening this week in Shenzhen, Dongguan and Guangzhou? Sign up to be notified when we launch the This Week @ Nanfang newsletter.

sign up for our newsletter

Nanfang TV